On this page8 sections
- An officer found the 2021 applicant eligible in June 2024, but no decision followed
- Two sets of Ministerial Instructions reshaped the queue
- The judge found the instructions caused the delay in this file
- The ruling has clear limits
- IRCC’s tool shows about 47,400 people waiting
- Applicants still waiting can take these steps
- Official sources
- Frequently asked questions
On 9 November 2026, Justice Michael Battista of the Federal Court decided a Start-up Visa mandamus case, Naghavi v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2026 FC 1370. He ordered IRCC to make a decision within 90 days on a Start-up Visa permanent residence application filed in March 2021.
The judgment decides this one file. The judge wrote that each mandamus request turns on its own facts, and that IRCC could succeed in a future case with stronger justification. Another Federal Court judge refused a similar request in Jin v. Canada, 2026 FC 1080. The order requires a decision, not an approval, so IRCC can still refuse the application.
An officer found the 2021 applicant eligible in June 2024, but no decision followed
The applicant applied in March 2021 with a commitment from a designated business incubator. According to IRCC’s case notes (GCMS), as described in the decision, an officer found him eligible and not inadmissible in June 2024, and the file was marked ready for finalization. No final decision followed.
Two sets of Ministerial Instructions moved two other groups of Start-up Visa applicants ahead of him. The Court put the delay at 67 months, about five and a half years. In September 2026 IRCC estimated 31 more months, but its own evidence said that figure did not include the effect of the December 2025 instructions. The judge wrote that “it is realistic to anticipate that the processing time for the application will approach a decade.”
Two sets of Ministerial Instructions reshaped the queue
Section 87.3 of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act (IRPA) lets the Minister set the order and annual number of applications processed, including for applications already waiting.
- April 2024 instructions (MI72). Dated 11 April 2024 and in force from 30 April 2024, they limited each designated entity to 10 accepted commitment certificates a year. They gave priority to files backed by a venture capital fund (at least $200,000), an angel investor group (at least $75,000), or a business incubator that is a Canada’s Tech Network member or committed at least $75,000, including files already in the queue.
- December 2025 instructions (MI90). In force from 1 January 2026 “until further notice”, they replaced MI72 and set new Start-up Visa applications at zero, with a narrow exception for commitments made in 2025. Files with a qualifying commitment and a team member holding a Start-up Visa work permit moved to the front, followed by other qualifying commitments, and this applied to files already waiting.
The judge found the instructions caused the delay in this file
The judge accepted that Ministerial Instructions can justify delay, and that the Minister may issue successive instructions to prioritize applications. In this case, the judge wrote: “I have determined that the MIs have been the perpetrators rather than the justification for open-ended delay. It is circular reasoning to accept the cause of open-ended delay as the justification for open-ended delay.”
He also wrote that “as long as the Minister chooses to keep applications in a processing queue, a duty to reasonably process those applications is engaged”, and noted that caps and pauses are among the Minister’s options. That is reasoning in one judgment, not an IRCC rule.
The formal judgment granted judicial review and mandamus, required a decision within 90 days of 9 November 2026, certified no question for appeal and made no order on costs.
The ruling has clear limits
- IRCC argued that granting mandamus would entitle every Start-up Visa applicant to it. The judge called that concern misplaced: “Mandamus is a discretionary remedy and each request for mandamus turns on its particular facts.”
- In Jin, Justice Negar Azmudeh declined mandamus under the same instructions. Justice Battista distinguished it because it was not based on a finding of open-ended delay.
- The appeal-court test this judgment applied, from Benison v. Canada (RCMP External Review Committee), 2026 FCA 53, is now before the Supreme Court of Canada.
- Under IRPA section 74(d), an appeal to the Federal Court of Appeal requires a certified question, and the judge did not certify one.
IRCC’s tool shows about 47,400 people waiting
IRCC’s program page lists the Start-up Visa as “Paused”. Applying required a valid 2025 commitment certificate and an application by 30 June 2026, and the program is closed to all other applications. Other routes for entrepreneurs are covered in Start-up Visa paused: entrepreneur routes to Canada.
IRCC’s processing-times tool, updated 17 November 2026, shows about 47,400 people waiting for a Start-up Visa decision. Its estimates of time left:
| Application month | IRCC estimate of time left |
|---|---|
| March 2021 | 31 months (about 1,300 people ahead) |
| June 2021 | 45 months |
| April 2022 or later | More than 10 years |
The March 2021 figure matches the estimate in Naghavi. IRCC says its projections “may change” and that the time left can also increase. They describe the Start-up Visa queue, not any one file.
Applicants still waiting can take these steps
- Check your own application month in IRCC’s processing-times tool.
- Request your GCMS notes, which show what officers have recorded about your file, including whether eligibility and admissibility have been assessed.
- Keep a dated record of every IRCC request, reply and follow-up.
- If you hold a Start-up Visa work permit, IRCC says you may be able to extend it while your permanent residence application is being processed.
- Ask IRCC in writing for a decision. The guide to mandamus for IRCC delay explains the test the Court applies.
- Know who can go to court. Mandamus starts with an application for leave to the Federal Court (IRPA section 72(1)). Under rule 119 of the Federal Courts Rules, you may act in person or be represented by a solicitor. A Regulated Canadian Immigration Consultant is neither, so a consultant cannot represent you in the Federal Court (see immigration lawyer vs RCIC).
Official sources
- Federal Court: Naghavi v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2026 FC 1370, docket IMM-17672-25, 9 November 2026
- IRCC: Start-up Visa Program
- IRCC: Check processing times
- IRCC: Ministerial Instructions 72 and Ministerial Instructions 90
- Canada Gazette, Part I, 4 May 2024 and 20 December 2025
- Immigration and Refugee Protection Act and Federal Courts Rules
If your Start-up Visa application has been waiting and you want a clear view of where it stands, you can book a consultation or order your GCMS notes.
This article is general information, not legal advice. Hadi Imani is a Regulated Canadian Immigration Consultant, licence R522575, practising in Toronto.
Frequently asked questions
Does this ruling apply to every Start-up Visa applicant?
No. It decides one file. The judge wrote that each mandamus request turns on its own facts, and in Jin (2026 FC 1080) a different Federal Court judge refused mandamus under the same instructions.
Did the Court order IRCC to approve the application?
No. The Court ordered IRCC to make a decision within 90 days. That decision can be an approval or a refusal.
Can I still apply for the Start-up Visa?
No. IRCC lists the program as paused. The last route required a valid 2025 commitment certificate and an application by 30 June 2026.
Can an immigration consultant file a mandamus application for me?
No. Mandamus is a Federal Court proceeding that you conduct yourself or through a lawyer. A consultant can help you request GCMS notes, write to IRCC and organize your timeline before you speak to one.
About this guide
Written by Hadi Imani (registered name Hadi Imani Maman), Regulated Canadian Immigration Consultant, CICC licence R522575.
Found something out of date? Tell us
